UPDATE Fri July 1 - We got a second opinion on Sweetpea and I am so glad we did.
Dr Ann is a bit of a drive but well worth it. We took a half hour just to go over all the tests and paperwork form the other vet - trying to make sense of it all. Dr Ann had me leave Sweetpea with her for the rest of the day so she could run a few more tests of her own.
Turns out Sweetpea is NOT diabetic but she does have elevated liver values and a mild UTI.. Sweetpea is on Clavamox for the UTI. The thyroid meds or the not eating could cause the high liver numbers so for the next week we will make sure Sweetpea eats (she ate on her own tonight) and NOT give the thyroid meds. We have appetite stimulants to give Sweetpea and Dr Ann did some acupuncture to stimulate her appetite too and to tone the liver.
We will take Sweetpea back to Dr Ann next week to get more blood work and see if the numbers are different. At this point with all the crazy stuff going on from the old vet, I am sure she must wonder if she is hyperthyroid after all.
The old vet was one I had been seeing for years for many of the other cats and did not have any problems except some issues with Georgie. At this point, I am not going back there for sure. Dr Ann is worth the drive and I will be going to her from now on! I like her blend of holistic and conventional vet care. Thanks for all the comments, suggestions and support. I have been a wreck this week!